What is alleged
Becker's Payer reported on November 6, 2026 that Elevance Health filed suit on November 4 in New York state court against The Perfect Child, an in-network ABA provider, and its owner, Simcha Bendet. Everything below is an allegation from the complaint as Becker's describes it. None of it has been proven.
Elevance alleges that after members completed intake, the provider moved them without telling them to out-of-network entities that the owner owned or controlled, more than 100 in all. It alleges that the defendants waived member cost sharing and threatened collection actions against members who questioned the billing. It alleges that the provider itself billed Elevance plans under $500,000 since 2020, while the affiliated entities billed about $800 million since 2021, and that Elevance has paid those entities more than $160 million. Elevance says it denied more than $102 million in claims as duplicates and cut $70 million in billed charges that exceeded usual and customary amounts. It alleges the owner created more entities to avoid pre-payment review after Elevance asked for more documentation.
Elevance seeks damages, punitive damages and legal fees on eight counts, including breach of contract, fraud and civil conspiracy.
The contract
Elevance says it gave the provider notice on June 5 that it was terminating the provider agreement effective September 3. Becker's reports this as the complaint's account and does not independently document the notice.
What we have not verified
We read Becker's Payer, not the complaint. We did not read a second outlet. Becker's says it asked The Perfect Child for comment and reports no response. Becker's also cites a November 3 Wall Street Journal report of a federal investigation, which Becker's does not confirm and which we did not read, so we do not repeat it.
Why it matters to an operator
Analysis: This is a payer, not a regulator, using a civil suit to enforce its network rules, which fits the pattern that the regulator writes the rule and the payer, the auditor and the buyer enforce it. The allegations turn on affiliated entities, member steering and cost sharing waivers, so any operator with related entities billing the same payers should be able to show, on paper, who renders each service, who bills it, and how members were told about network status. Nothing here has been decided, and a payer's allegations are not a finding.
If a payer has questioned your billing or your affiliated entities, the payer and Medicaid advisory helps you prepare an audit file, alongside your counsel.
Book a free 30 minute scoping callEngagements are business and compliance advisory, delivered alongside your counsel, who provides legal advice. Nothing here is legal advice.
This brief rests on the reporting linked above and is labeled accordingly. Dossiers on this site are read to primary sources. Education only; nothing here is legal advice.
ABAWiser provides research, analysis, and compliance advisory services. We are not a law firm, we do not provide legal advice, and no engagement creates an attorney client relationship. Dossiers track developments as they occur and may be incomplete or updated as a story evolves. Confirm any statutory or regulatory point against the primary source before acting on it.